0
IdentityGroup

My Thoughts

Why Traditional Networking Events Are Making Us Worse at Building Real Business Relationships

Related Articles:

Walk into any networking event in Sydney or Melbourne these days and you'll see the same depressing theatre. Blokes in cheap suits clutching business cards like they're golden tickets, desperately trying to make "meaningful connections" while simultaneously checking their phones every thirty seconds. Women in blazers they clearly hate, forcing smiles whilst internally calculating how many more handshakes they need before they can escape to the pub.

I've been watching this train wreck for seventeen years now, and I'm calling it: traditional networking is not just broken—it's actively making us worse at building genuine business relationships.

The Card Collector Syndrome

Here's what really gets my goat about these events. Everyone's become a business card collector instead of a relationship builder. Last month at a Chamber of Commerce do in Brisbane, I watched a property developer work the room like he was harvesting wheat. Thirty-seven business cards in ninety minutes. When I asked him about the third person he'd met, he couldn't even remember their name.

But here's the kicker—he felt successful because his wallet was bulging with cards.

This obsession with quantity over quality is destroying the very thing networking was supposed to create: trust. You can't build trust in a two-minute conversation between the canapés and the cash bar. Trust develops over time, through repeated interactions, shared experiences, and—here's a radical thought—actually helping each other without expecting immediate returns.

Why Aussie Networking Feels So Bloody Awkward

There's something uniquely uncomfortable about professional networking in Australia that nobody wants to acknowledge. We're culturally wired to be suspicious of people who come on too strong, yet networking events reward exactly that behaviour.

The tall poppy syndrome meets desperate self-promotion, and it creates this weird dance where everyone's trying to sell themselves whilst pretending they're not selling themselves. It's like watching people try to speak French when they've only done Duolingo for a week—technically correct but painfully obvious.

I've noticed this particularly in Perth and Adelaide, where the business communities are smaller and everyone knows everyone. The forced networking becomes even more absurd when you're essentially performing enthusiasm about meeting people you've known for years.

The LinkedIn Connection Lie

Don't even get me started on what happens after these events. Within 24 hours, you'll receive seventeen LinkedIn connection requests from people who spent exactly ninety seconds talking to you about the weather. Their messages all sound like they were written by the same AI: "Great meeting you at [event name]. Let's connect and explore synergies."

Synergies! As if Bob from accounting software sales is going to revolutionise your business model through the power of professional social media connections.

The real crime here is that these shallow connections actually crowd out space for meaningful relationships. Your LinkedIn feed becomes this endless stream of motivational quotes and humble brags from people you barely know, drowning out the updates from the handful of people you actually care about professionally.

What Actually Works (And Why Nobody Does It)

Here's what I've learned about building business relationships that matter: stop trying to network and start trying to help.

The best professional relationships I've built happened when I wasn't trying to build them. They emerged from working on projects together, solving problems collectively, or—revolutionary concept—just having genuine conversations about things that weren't directly related to extracting value from each other.

Take the partnership I built with a training consultant in Geelong five years ago. We met at a café near the waterfront, both killing time before different meetings in the same building. Started chatting about the shocking coffee service (it was actually decent, but we were both having bad days). Ended up collaborating on three major projects. Not because we exchanged business cards, but because we had a real conversation about real problems.

The secret sauce? Neither of us was trying to sell anything to the other. We were just two professionals having a whinge about our respective industries over surprisingly good flat whites.

The Small Business Reality

Small business owners get hit particularly hard by networking mythology because they're told they "need" to network to survive. So they dutifully show up to breakfast meetings at 6:30 AM, when they'd rather be home with their families or actually working on their businesses.

Here's the uncomfortable truth: most small businesses would be better off spending that networking time improving their products or services. Your existing customers are your best source of new business, not strangers at the local BNI chapter who are obligated to refer business to you because of some arbitrary weekly quota system.

I watched a brilliant graphic designer in Darwin nearly burn out trying to maintain relationships with dozens of people she'd met at networking events. She was spending more time on coffee meetings than actual design work. When she stopped networking and started focusing on exceeding her existing clients' expectations, her business doubled in eighteen months.

Her clients became her sales force. Naturally. Authentically. Without a single "let's explore synergies" conversation.

The Authenticity Problem

Modern networking advice tells you to "be authentic," which is hilarious because the entire structure of networking events makes authenticity nearly impossible. When you know everyone's trying to evaluate your potential value as a business contact, every conversation becomes performative.

Real authenticity in business relationships means admitting when you don't know something. It means recommending competitors when they're better suited to solve someone's problem. It means having conversations about your kids' school fees or your thoughts on the latest season of whatever everyone's binge-watching.

But try being genuinely authentic at a networking event and watch how quickly people's eyes glaze over. They didn't come to hear about your struggles with work-life balance; they came to find leads.

The Technology Trap

Digital networking platforms promised to solve traditional networking's problems but mostly just scaled them up. Now instead of collecting business cards, we're collecting LinkedIn connections. Instead of awkward small talk at events, we're sliding into DMs with templates we found on YouTube.

The fundamental problem remains: we're treating relationship building like a numbers game rather than recognising that meaningful professional relationships are rare, valuable, and impossible to force.

I know successful business owners who have fewer than 200 LinkedIn connections but could pick up the phone and have a genuine, helpful conversation with any of them. Compare that to the networking enthusiasts with 3,000 connections who couldn't tell you what most of their contacts actually do for work.

The Alternative Approach

Instead of networking events, try industry conferences where you're there to learn, not to collect contacts. Join professional associations where you can contribute meaningfully over time. Volunteer for causes you care about alongside other professionals who share your values.

Better yet, just be excellent at what you do and generous with your knowledge. Write helpful content. Answer questions in industry forums. Share resources without expecting anything in return. The right professional relationships will emerge naturally from these activities because they're based on genuine mutual respect rather than calculated networking strategies.

The most valuable professional contact I've made in the last five years reached out after reading something I'd written about workplace training. We'd never met, never been to the same networking event, never exchanged business cards. But we'd both been solving similar problems for our respective clients, and a real collaboration emerged from that shared expertise.

The Bottom Line

Traditional networking isn't just ineffective—it's teaching us to approach professional relationships in ways that undermine trust and authenticity. We're turning business relationship building into a transactional activity when the best professional relationships are fundamentally non-transactional.

Stop trying to network. Start trying to be helpful, knowledgeable, and genuinely interested in solving problems. The relationships that matter will follow.

And for the love of all that's holy, stop collecting business cards like Pokémon cards. Quality over quantity, every single time.

Our Favourite Blogs: